A line drawing shows the data collection, transmission and processing modules that a BSM-based traffic state estimator would require for traffic management.

MnDOT Prepares to Use Future Vehicle-to-Vehicle Messaging

Manufacturers are developing vehicles that can “talk” to each other. “Connected vehicles” will be able to convey their position, speed and acceleration. Sending this information to other vehicles and relevant infrastructure is expected to enhance highway safety, but it also may help transportation agencies better manage traffic.

While it may be a decade before vehicle-to-vehicle messaging is common, MnDOT is interested in learning how it can prepare for and use this messaging for traffic management before connected vehicles become the norm. 

In a new MnDOT-sponsored study, University of Minnesota researchers developed a traffic state estimator that can use data from these future basic safety messages (BSMs) instead of from less accurate loop detectors and highway cameras to convey the real-time state of traffic on highways.

“We developed and tested a novel methodology for using basic safety message transmissions from connected vehicles to estimate the traffic state, which could be used to augment or replace current sensors used for traffic controls and traffic information displays,” said Michael Levin, assistant professor, University of Minnesota Department of Civil, Environment and Geo-Engineering.

MnDOT’s Regional Transportation Management Center (RTMC) oversees systems that control nearly a million vehicles daily in the Twin Cities area. It uses data from loop detectors in pavement, freeway cameras, radar detectors and other sources to determine estimated traffic states and make traffic operation decisions. However, loop detectors can fail and cameras can be obscured, making it difficult to measure traffic density. Better real-time traffic data would allow the RTMC to improve traffic flow, enhancing safety and saving money. 

What Was Our Goal?

This project’s primary objective was to use BSMs within a model to create a traffic state estimator that could provide traffic measurements at high resolution. The overall goal was to provide MnDOT with tools and methodology to use BSMs for traffic management as soon as they are available and minimize the transition time required to shift to a data system based on connected vehicles. 

What Did We Do?

Data sources and methodologies for traffic state estimation have changed with the rapid evolution of communications technologies. Researchers initially conducted a literature search of recent publications to examine methods of traffic state estimation. 

Using raw data from the Minnesota Traffic Observatory, researchers translated hundreds of thousands of vehicle trajectories from I-94 in downtown Minneapolis to emulate BSMs. With this extensive library of traffic conditions, researchers developed a traffic state estimation algorithm using a Kalman filter technique that combines information from a prediction model and real-world measurement, which is more accurate than using a model or measures alone. The cell transmission model was used with speed measures extracted from BSMs and data from loop detectors. This type of model divides a target road section into short segments, or cells—the basic unit for this project’s traffic state estimator. The output is the density, speed and exiting flow of each cell.

A highway map shows the position of radar sensors (red circles) and the coverage area of each radar unit (colored rectangles).
The new traffic state estimator was evaluated on a section of I-94 in Minneapolis. This map shows the location of radar sensors (red circles) and the area monitored by each device (overlapping colored rectangles).

Researchers used several test data sets, including other computer models and radar data, to evaluate how accurately the traffic state estimator generated estimated density, speed, flow, travel times and queue lengths. They also conducted analyses that predicted the filter’s sensitivity as increasingly more BSM-equipped vehicles use the roadway (from 20% to 100% market penetration).

To understand the computing power this system would require, researchers constructed a traffic monitoring system that consisted of robust data collection, transmission and processing modules. Finally, researchers determined the kind of infrastructure the traffic state estimator would require in the field and the benefits MnDOT would gain from using the system. 

What Was the Result? 

A traffic state estimator based upon selected BSMs is within reach for MnDOT. The literature search revealed that the Kalman filter used for this project is widely accepted as more accurate than predictive models or direct measures alone, and that cell transmission models are widely used. 

“This project helped us understand how we might use messaging from connected vehicles to improve our estimates of travel times and other traffic measures,” said Ray Starr, assistant state traffic engineer, MnDOT Office of Traffic Engineering. 

Researchers were able to scale up their model to represent a 20% to 100% presence of BSM vehicles on Minnesota roadways. The evaluations of the project’s traffic state estimator results compared to other traffic models, radar data and actual roadway situations were very promising. The project also showed where further improvements could be made. Most important, researchers presented a workable methodology and steps the agency can take to make full use of data from connected vehicles. 

They also identified infrastructure additions that would be required to use a BSM-based traffic state estimator for traffic management. These additions include many roadside units to collect BSM data and robust computing power to quickly run the appropriate algorithms on an ever-increasing rush of real-time data. RTMC would be able to translate this new data to improve traffic operations wherever the new system could be implemented. 

What’s Next?

The project showed proof of concept and generated much useful data and questions for the future. MnDOT does not have current plans for further research in this area but will consider the results of this as well as national research such as NCHRP 03-137, Algorithms to Convert Basic Safety Messages Into Traffic Measures, in future planning.

Related Links

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s